Knight Ridder Election 2004
krwashington
 Around the World
 Correspondents
 Special Reports
 Washington

 Back to your local site:
 



  Related links

InstaPundit.com: Smart, lively commentary from mostly right-leaning bloggers.

Talking Points Memo: Joshua Micah Marshall's take from left of center.

Blogs for Bush: The other side's take on all the action in the Democratic primary.





Welcome to Red State/Blue State, a feature presented by The Anniston Star of Anniston, Ala., and The Philadelphia Inquirer.

In the December 2001 edition of the Atlantic, David Brooks wrote an essay titled "One Nation, Slightly Divisible," in which he suggested that America is divided largely into two political cultures, one "red" and one "blue." His idea is based on those electoral maps in 2000 that colored majority-Republican states in red and majority-Democratic states in blue. Brooks' witty essay pictures the red-state voter as trending rural, a salt-of-the-earth type, concerned with individual liberty and family values, whereas the "blue" voter trends urban, more of a book-reader, a Beltway-savvy intellectual, the environmentally conscious soccer mom or dad.

Cliches? Maybe. But Brooks does have his finger on two very strong currents in the American votership. It's not that Pennsylvania is a "blue state" or Alabama is a "red state." It's that our two political cultures don't talk to each other much, or even know much about each other. To bridge that gap, we've brought together two "red" voters - John Franklin and Cynthia Sneed - and two "blue" voters, Terri Falbo and Timothy Horner. Each week, they'll ponder and debate the issues arising in the election campaign. The hope is that they'll model an intelligent discussion, a great big conference room where red and blue sit down together.

Monday, October 04, 2004

Joe Franklin, Red Stater 

Question Number Ten: Do you like the format for the debates? Is it a "real debate"? Do we ever learn significant things about the candidates from these debates? What would you rather see?

The mention of "da bait" in South Alabama brings thoughts of crickets, worms and fishing on the creek. It is kinda like "da fence." People think of net wire and barbed wire.

We don't have debates. We have discussions, arguments, heated arguments, cuss-outs and occasionally fights. I understand the presidential debate required teams of lawyers and a 32-page contract. If the difference of opinion among the common folk required preparation of a 32-page contract, Saturday nights at the county jail would be much quieter.

The idea of a contract brings to mind fights of young boys in elementary school. There was no biting, no hair pulling, no kicking, no scratching, no eye gouging, and no spittin'.

I've never had a debating course and have no regrets. The presidential debate format seems more like a staged, controlled, or scripted news interview or news conference.

The questions should come from those participating and not the commission or moderator.

I'd rather see more head-to-head action. As it is now, we learn who's the slick talker and who has the best make-up artist, hairstylist and manicurists.

Third-party candidates are virtually eliminated. Many commentaries and editorials refer to how equally divided this county is politically. I think the divisiveness of many elections would not be the case if third parties were included in our process. A viable third-party candidate can make Democrats and Republicans, alike, the party of big money. Does Democracy require a two-party system?

The Commission on Presidential Debates is neither nonpartisan or neutral. The Presidential Debates were stolen from the League of Women Voters years ago after their inclusion of thir-party candidates. We may have women's rights, but I can just imagine the alpha males (big dogs) of the Democratic and Republican parties meeting somewhere in a back room plotting to take control of the debates from the women, with all those alpha males sharing the idea, "We can't have this bunch of women running the presidential debate."

The most significant product of the debates are the one-line "zingers" that are repeated many times on news broadcasts and talk shows. These remarks leave a lasting impression where policy and rhetoric soon fade away.

I did learn that four of my neighbors went to sleep while watching the debates. The majority stated prior to the debates, "Heck no, I ain't watching no debate."

During the debates the candidates praise themselves, criticize the opponent, defend accusations made against them, and give no specifics as to what they will do for the voters. The debates are much too formal and stiff. Maybe this is why most voters find the spin shows more interesting. That's why the percentage of viewers for televised presidential debates has drastically declined in the past 40 years. These days, no one watches except pseudointellectuals, political sophisticates and party diehards.

I think that we should take a look at some of the old-fashioned political rallies, which included name-calling and finger-pointing. The promise of more action would interest more viewers, and perhaps my neighbors could stay awake.



  Archives

   •  08/01/2004 - 08/08/2004
   •  08/08/2004 - 08/15/2004
   •  08/15/2004 - 08/22/2004
   •  08/22/2004 - 08/29/2004
   •  08/29/2004 - 09/05/2004
   •  09/05/2004 - 09/12/2004
   •  09/12/2004 - 09/19/2004
   •  09/19/2004 - 09/26/2004
   •  09/26/2004 - 10/03/2004
   •  10/03/2004 - 10/10/2004
   •  10/10/2004 - 10/17/2004
   •  10/24/2004 - 10/31/2004
   •  10/31/2004 - 11/07/2004
   •  11/07/2004 - 11/14/2004


Bloggers from
Blue State (Pa.)


Terri Falbo

Born and raised in Southwestern Pennsylvania, Terri Falbo is a union organizer who has lived in Philadelphia for almost 30 years. She graduated from Temple University and previously worked as a construction worker for 17 years.

Tim Horner

Tim Horner grew up in Iowa, but has lived out significant chunks of his adult life in Chicago, IL and Oxford, England. He is married and has four children (14, 12, 10 and 7). Having grown up as an Evangelical in the Midwest and still a practicing Christian, he is concerned with how religion and politics mix. Because of a combination of circumstance and apathy, he has never voted in a presidential election. He currently teaches Humanities at Villanova University.
Bloggers from
Red State (Ala.)


Joe Franklin

Alabama native Joe Franklin, 58, was born in Pike County and grew up on a farm in Crenshaw County. He graduated from Troy State University in 1967. After working for 28 years with the Alabama Board of Pardons and Paroles as a parole and probation officer, retired to Crenshaw County, which is just south of Montgomery, where he spends his days working on the farm.


Cynthia Sneed

Gadsden resident and local college professor Cynthia Smith Sneed has a doctorate in Accounting from the University of Alabama. Her fields of academic research are in state pension and employee benefit issues. She has been published in numerous academic accounting journals and has done research for the Alabama Policy Institute. She is a member of the American Accounting Association, Governmental Finance Officers Association as well as being active in the Republican Party.



About Realcities Network | About Knight Ridder | Terms of Use & Privacy Statement

Copyright 2004 Knight Ridder. All rights reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any
of the contents of this service without the express written consent of Knight Ridder is expressly prohibited.